+1 is Explicit, but is not Relevance Feedback

A week or so ago, Google introduced it’s answer to the Facebook “Like”.  It is called “+1″.  Here is a quote from the official announcement:

The +1 button is shorthand for “this is pretty cool” or “you should check this out.”  Click +1 to publicly give something your stamp of approval. Your +1′s can help friends, contacts, and others on the web find the best stuff when they search.

A discussion then ensued on Twitter about whether Google had finally introduced explicit relevance feedback to its system.  For a long time, the user has been able to give implicit signals of preference to the search engine algorithm in the form of click-throughs.  And conventional wisdom has held that users are too lazy or to disinterested to interact with a web search engine in any explicit manner beyond typing 2.7 keywords into the one-line search box.  But now Google has introduced the +1.  Does this mean that explicit relevance feedback is finally here?

My answer is no.  And it is important to understand why.

First of all, Continue reading…